Back to Friday Series

    American BBQ Food Review

    Surly's American Tavern

    8.2/10
    182 Campbell St, Surry Hills NSW 2010
    May 2, 2026

    A strong, satisfying BBQ spread with a clear winner: the sauce.


    Highlights:

    -Brisket (top-tier BBQ moment)

    -Cornbread (my first time trying)

    -That sauce (obsessed is an understatement)

    We went all in on American barbecue and honestly… this was proper comfort food territory. Smoky, rich, saucy, and just the right amount of messy.


    A full lineup of slow-cooked meats, hearty sides, drinks, and plenty of sauce tying it all together.


    Beef Brisket: 9/10

    Starting strong with this-and it delivered.

    Super tender, juicy, and packed with that classic smoky flavour. Even without being a brisket expert, you can tell this is good quality.


    Verdict: A standout. Solid, satisfying, and exactly what you want from BBQ.


    Sausage: 8/10

    A reliable addition to the spread.

    Flavourful with a good bite, but what really elevates it is the sauce situation happening here.


    Verdict: Great on its own, even better loaded up with condiments.


    Cornbread: 8.5/10

    A little surprise moment.

    Slightly sweet, soft, and buttery-not what you expect if you’ve never had it before, but it works.


    Verdict: Unexpectedly delicious. A must-try side.


    Pulled Pork: 8/10

    Juicy and not dry in the slightest.

    Soaks up sauce beautifully and delivers that rich, slow-cooked flavor.


    Verdict: A strong player, especially if you’re a sauce lover.


    Chicken: 7/10

    Good, but overshadowed.

    Tender and well-cooked, just not as exciting as the other meats on the table.


    Verdict: Solid, but not the star.


    Wings: 7/10

    Better with sauce (obviously).

    On their own, they’re decent-but once you dip? Whole different story.


    Verdict: Sauce carries here. Still enjoyable.


    Buffalo Wings with Ranch: 7/10

    A bit of a letdown texture - wise.

    Needed more sauce - definitely on the drier side - but still tasty with the ranch.


    Verdict: Good flavor, just needed more of that “wet wing” energy.


    Fries (Shoestring): No Rating

    Crispy potential was there, but condensation got in the way.

    Still… shoestring fries always win.


    Verdict: Right idea, just unlucky timing.


    Pickles & House Sauce: 12/10 (Yes, 12)

    The real MVP.

    Tangy, punchy, addictive-this sauce absolutely steals the show. The pickles cut through all the richness perfectly.


    Verdict: Elite. Life-changing. Send bottles immediately.


    Root Beer: 7.5/10

    First time trying - and it holds up.

    Very sarsaparilla/Dr Pepper vibes. Sweet, herbal, slightly nostalgic.


    Verdict: Acquired taste, but surprisingly enjoyable.

    Watch the Video

    New recipes, straight to you

    Join the list and never miss a recipe drop. No spam, just flavour.