Back to Friday Series

    Bakery Review

    Bourke Street Bakery Surry Hills

    8.9/10
    633 Bourke St, Surry Hills NSW 2010
    May 1, 2026

    This is exactly what a great bakery run feels like-warm pastry, strong execution across the board, and that perfect mix of savoury and sweet comfort food.


    Highlights:

    -Brisket pie (absolute must-order)

    -Carrot cake (elite tier)

    -Chocolate milk (dangerously good)

    Tucking into one of Sydney’s OG bakeries today and let me just say… this one delivered exactly what it’s known for. Proper cold-weather comfort food, flaky pastry everywhere, and absolutely no restraint required.


    We worked through a mix of savoury pies, sausage rolls, drinks, and a full sweet line-up-and yeah, this was peak bakery energy.


    Here’s how everything stacked up:


    Brisket Pie + House-made Tomato Sauce: 8.9/10

    Starting STRONG.

    Chunky, rich brisket filling wrapped in buttery, flaky pastry that basically falls apart in the best way. The gravy is deep, savoury, and super well-seasoned, and the tomato sauce just ties everything together with that slightly tangy sweetness.


    Verdict: Proper hearty pie done right. Full-flavour, no notes.


    Pork & Fennel Sausage Roll: 8.6/10

    Simple, classic, and ridiculously satisfying.

    The fennel is the standout here-fragrant, slightly sweet, and balancing the richness of the pork perfectly. Pastry is crisp, golden, and holds everything together without getting heavy.


    Verdict: A cold-day essential. Clean, comforting, reliable.


    House-made Chocolate Milk: 9.1/10

    Unexpected highlight.

    Thickened slightly with Belgian chocolate, making it rich without being over-the-top. Creamy, smooth, and exactly what you want from a proper chocolate milk-just missing a touch more intensity to push it into elite territory.


    Verdict: Dangerous in the best way. Could easily become a habit drink.


    Carrot Cake: 9.3/10

    This one absolutely delivered.

    Incredibly moist (yes, it counts), soft crumb, and packed with warmth from spice. The cream cheese frosting is rich, tangy, and perfectly balanced-not too sweet, just right.


    Verdict: One of the best carrot cakes out there. No exaggeration.


    Ginger Brûlée Tart: 8.8/10

    A surprise favourite.

    Buttery pastry, smooth ginger filling, and that caramelised brûlée top adding a subtle bitterness that cuts through the sweetness beautifully. Comforting but still interesting.


    Verdict: Sophisticated flavour balance. Underrated gem.


    Pain au Chocolat: 8.5/10

    Classic croissant moment.

    Flaky, buttery layers with good chocolate distribution, though slightly less indulgent than the dream version (a little more chocolate would’ve pushed it higher). Still very solid and very enjoyable.


    Verdict: A dependable croissant-simple done well.

    Watch the Video

    New recipes, straight to you

    Join the list and never miss a recipe drop. No spam, just flavour.