Back to Friday Series

    Pie Review

    The Pie Father

    8.4/10
    437 Gardeners Rd, Rosebery NSW 2018
    May 1, 2026

    A fun, creative bakery lineup that actually backs up the gimmick with solid flavour. Not every pie is subtle-but that’s kind of the point.


    Highlights:

    -Big Mick Pie (absolute standout)

    -Reuben Pie (surprisingly elite)

    -Mac & cheese (comfort win)

    Going full throttle on creative pies or over-the-top meat pies today and let me just say… this was peak Aussie bakery chaos in the best way possible. Classic flavours reimagined, awards on the wall, and absolutely zero subtlety, just straight-up flavour bombs in pastry form.


    We worked through a mix of savoury pies, a drink, and a nostalgic dessert finish-and yeah, this one delivered on the gimmick and the taste.


    Mac & Cheese Pie: 7.9/10

    Starting with the comfort classic.

    Creamy, cheesy filling tucked into flaky pastry, and honestly… it works way better than expected. Rich, indulgent, and slightly over-the-top in a good way. A little salt would’ve pushed it even further.


    Verdict: Gimmicky on paper, solid in reality.


    Reuben Pie: 8.5/10

    This is where things got interesting.

    Classic Reuben flavours-pastrami, tangy sauce, and that deli-style profile-all packed into a pie. It genuinely tastes like a sandwich that somehow turned into pastry, and it works.


    Verdict: Bold concept, executed really well. Slightly addictive.


    Bundaberg Raspberry & Pomegranate: 8/10

    A fizzy reset between pies.

    Sweet, fruity, and refreshing, though definitely more “safe choice” than standout. Does the job, especially between heavier bites.


    Verdict: Solid, but could’ve been choccy milk.


    Big Mick Pie: 9/10

    This is the one.

    Straight-up Big Mac energy in pie form-beef, sauce, cheese vibes all layered into pastry. Messy, salty, saucy, and absolutely ridiculous in the best way. This is the flavour match people expect when they think “crazy pie.”


    Verdict: Fully unhinged, fully delicious. Best savoury of the day.


    Apple Turnover: 8.7/10

    A nostalgic finish.

    Flaky pastry, warm apple filling, and that classic bakery sweetness. Not the most refined version out there, but it hits that childhood comfort perfectly.


    Verdict: Simple, familiar, and satisfying.

    Watch the Video

    New recipes, straight to you

    Join the list and never miss a recipe drop. No spam, just flavour.