Alchemy Polish Cafe Restaurant
A Polish feast that kept us on our toes: a fishy opener that split the table, a dumpling plate that had everyone going quiet with joy, and a back half of hearty, old-world cooking that reminded us why grandma-style food never goes out of fashion.
Highlights:
-Pierogi with sour cream & bacon (easy win)
-Beetroot soup once you adjust to it
-Proper homestyle cabbage roll energy
Heading into Polish food from Alchemy in Surry Hills today and this one was a proper mix of “oh wow” and “I’m not sure about this but I respect it.”
We started strong, got a bit challenged, and ended on some seriously comforting Eastern European classics.
Herring in Cream & Onion: 5/10
Starting with the wildcard.
Creamy, oniony, and immediately very… intense. The texture is soft but the flavour hits with this sharp, almost acidic fish note right in the centre that really throws you off.
The pieces were also a bit large, which made it harder to ease into.
Verdict: Not terrible, just very much an acquired taste situation. Respectfully not the favourite of the day.
Pierogi (Polish Dumplings): 8/10
This is where things turned around.
Soft dumplings filled with mushroom and potato, absolutely loaded with sour cream, bacon, and fried onion on top. Exactly as it should be.
Rich, comforting, and super satisfying. Every bite hits differently depending on the filling, but the overall combo is elite.
Verdict: The definition of comfort food. Easily the highlight of the savoury run.
Beetroot Soup with Beef Ravioli: 7.5/10
This one is loud in every sense.
The beetroot base is earthy, sweet, and intense, almost like drinking straight beetroot juice but elevated. The beef ravioli inside balances it out really nicely and adds depth.
A bit chaotic, but in a good way once you lean into it.
Verdict: Unique, warming, and surprisingly moreish once you get past the initial shock.
Pork & Cabbage Roll with Mash: 7.5/10
Classic, homestyle, and feels like something passed down through generations.
The cabbage roll is soft, savoury, and paired really well with the mash and ham elements. Nothing overly complicated, just solid traditional cooking that delivers exactly what it promises.
Verdict: Simple, comforting, and authentic. No complaints.
Join the list and never miss a recipe drop. No spam, just flavour.