Back to recipes

    Carbonara Beans

    Spaghetti carbonara is one of the greatest dishes to ever exist, simple, rich, deeply satisfying and the kind of thing you genuinely crave. The problem? It's not exactly something you would want to eat every week unless you want to be horizontal on the couch wondering what just happened to you. Carbonara beans fix that entirely. All the silky, peppery, parmesan-loaded goodness of a classic carbonara swapped onto butter beans for a version that is high in protein, high in fibre and absolutely something you can justify on a regular weeknight.

    The technique here is identical to a real carbonara and that is exactly why it works so well. Low heat, tempered eggs, constant movement and patience. The egg and parmesan mixture gets tempered first using the hot fat from the pan so it comes up in temperature gradually before it ever touches the beans. Then the beans go in on the absolute lowest heat possible with a splash of their own liquid to warm through, the egg mixture gets poured over, and you stir continuously taking the pan on and off the heat as many times as you need to keep everything silky and scramble-free. The guanciale is the traditional choice and if you can find it, use it. The fat renders out slowly and becomes the most incredible cooking medium for everything that follows. If you can't track it down, speck or bacon with a good glug of quality olive oil gets you to a very similar place. The parmesan situation is also not negotiable, freshly grated aged parmigiano reggiano only. Pre-grated will not melt properly and the sauce will not come together the way it should. It is a small thing that makes a very big difference. The aquafaba (bean liquid) is your best friend throughout this whole process. Too thick, add more. Too runny, add more parmesan. You have full control and the ability to course correct at any point which, unlike a real carbonara, is extremely forgiving.
    Prep10
    Cook15
    Serves1-2

    Carbonara Beans

    Ingredients

    MetricImperial
    1×
    2 eggs (1 whole + 1 yolk)
    1/2 cup freshly grated Parmesan (I use aged parmigiano reggiano for extra protein, can’t use pre grated stuff, won’t melt properly)
    150g guanciale (couldn’t find it at my local so I used speck instead)
    Freshly cracked pepper
    400g butter beans, drained (but keep the liquid)

    Method

    1. 1

      Whisk together the whole egg, yolk and grated parmesan in a bowl with a generous amount of freshly cracked pepper. Set aside.

    2. 2

      If using guanciale, start it in a cold pan and let it render slowly. The fat is everything here. If using speck or bacon, add a good glug of quality olive oil and cook until deeply golden and crispy. Either way, you want maximum crispiness.

    3. 3

      Once crispy, temper the egg and parmesan mixture by slowly adding about 2 tbsp of the hot fat or oil from the pan into the bowl while whisking constantly. This brings the egg mixture up in temperature gradually so it doesn't scramble when it hits the pan. Do not skip this step.

    4. 4

      Add the drained butter beans to the pan on the lowest heat possible with 2 tbsp of the reserved bean liquid to help warm them through. Stir gently.

    5. 5

      Pour the tempered egg mixture over the beans and stir continuously, taking the pan on and off the heat as needed to control the temperature. The sauce should be silky and glossy. If it looks like it's catching at all, off the heat immediately and keep stirring.

    6. 6

      If the sauce is too thick, loosen it with more bean liquid a tablespoon at a time. Too runny? Add more parmesan. Adjust seasoning and serve immediately topped with extra pepper and the crispy guanciale or speck.

    Macros

    (approximate per serve, based on 2 serves) Calories: ~480 | Protein: 28g | Carbs: 28g | Fat: 28g Butter beans are doing serious work here - high fibre, high protein, and genuinely filling. Values based on speck with olive oil. Guanciale will push fat and calories slightly higher.

    *Macros will vary for different brands of ingredients

    Storage

    Best eaten immediately - the carbonara sauce will thicken and the silky texture is very hard to rescue once it sits. If you do have leftovers, store in the fridge for up to 2 days and reheat very gently in a pan on the lowest heat possible with a splash of bean liquid or water to loosen. Do not microwave it, the eggs will scramble and it will be a sad situation.

    Substitutions

    Guanciale: speck or bacon as I use here. Add a good glug of quality olive oil to compensate for the lower fat content Butter beans: cannellini beans are a direct swap. Chickpeas work too for a slightly nuttier flavour Parmigiano reggiano: pecorino romano is the other traditional carbonara cheese and works beautifully here. I used reggiano for a bit more of a protein hit. And remember, freshly grated only Bean liquid: a small splash of warm water works in a pinch if you've discarded the liquid, but the bean liquid adds a subtle starchiness that helps the sauce emulsify properly, similar to pasta water

    FAQs

    Why do I need to temper the eggs? Pouring cold egg mixture straight into a hot pan scrambles it immediately. Tempering brings the eggs up in temperature gradually by adding hot fat slowly while whisking, so by the time it hits the pan it's already partially warmed and far less likely to catch. It's the single most important technique in this recipe. My sauce scrambled, what went wrong? Heat was too high. Carbonara lives and dies by low heat and constant movement. If it catches, pull the pan off immediately and keep stirring, sometimes you can rescue it. Going forward, lowest heat possible and don't be afraid to take the pan completely off the burner. Is this actually high protein? 28g per serve is solid, especially for a vegetable-forward dish. The combination of eggs, parmesan and butter beans covers all your essential amino acids too, so it's complete protein across the bowl.
    Print

    Watch the Reel

    Comments

    0 comments

    Leave a Comment

    Loading comments…

    New recipes, straight to you

    Join the list and never miss a recipe drop. No spam, just flavour.