Back to recipes

    Tomato Soup & 3 Cheese Toastie

    Tomato soup is the epitome of my childhood and this is the version that takes it to another level entirely. Roasted, blitzed, silky smooth and absolutely incomplete without a three cheese sourdough toastie on the side for dunking. Heinz is cute and she will always be my childhood lover but this is nostalgia, elevated.

    Tomato soup is one of those dishes that is just hardwired into my childhood in the best possible way. Heinz, straight from the can, heated up on the stove until it was just hot enough, poured into a bowl and eaten with whatever bread was in the house. It was simple, it was comforting, and it tasted exactly like being seven years old with nowhere to be. That kind of nostalgia hits different and I don't think it ever fully goes away. This is that memory, but grown up and done properly. Same soul, completely elevated, and with a three cheese toastie on the side that the Heinz can version absolutely deserved but never got. Because here's the thing about a smooth, texture-free soup - and tomato soup is the prime example of this - it is legally and morally incomplete without something to dunk and mop with. A silky, velvety soup with nothing on the side is just a sad situation and I will not be entertaining it. The toastie is not optional. The toastie is the whole point. The soup starts in the oven and this is the step that separates a good tomato soup from a genuinely great one. Roasting the tomatoes, onion, chilli and a whole bulb of garlic until everything is blistered, caramelised and deeply sweet transforms the flavour completely. You're not just cooking tomatoes, you're concentrating every bit of natural sweetness and driving off the raw acidity to create something rich and complex before it even hits the blender. Those juices left on the tray go in too - don't you dare leave them behind. The roasted garlic is the secret weapon here. Squeezed straight out of the skins after roasting it becomes this soft, sweet, almost jammy paste that dissolves into the soup and adds a depth that raw garlic simply cannot replicate. If you've never roasted a whole bulb of garlic before this is your moment and you will never stop doing it. The tomato paste gets cooked out in the pot first until it darkens and loses that sharp raw edge, then the blended soup goes in with the stock and a knob of butter that makes the whole thing silky and rich. Ten minutes of simmering and it's done. Genuinely one of the most flavourful soups you will ever make and it costs almost nothing. Heinz is great and I will always have love for it but this is on another level entirely. Now, the toastie. Aged cheddar for that deep salty flavour, mozzarella for the stretch and pull that goes absolutely everywhere, and parmesan for that extra hit of umami that ties the whole thing together. Piled generously onto white sourdough, buttered on the outside, pressed down in a hot pan until deeply golden and the cheese is fully, completely, gloriously melted. That moment when you drag it through the soup and the cheese pulls and the bread soaks up every last drop is, genuinely, one of life's great pleasures. Seven year old me would be absolutely losing it.
    Prep15
    Cook45
    Serves4

    Tomato Soup & 3 Cheese Toastie

    Ingredients

    MetricImperial
    1×

    To roast

    600g tomatoes
    1 red onion, roughly chopped
    1 red chili, with seeds, sliced lengthways
    1 bulb of garlic, whole, tops removed
    1 tbsp olive oil
    1 tsp dried basil
    1/2 tsp dried oregano
    1/2 tsp dried thyme
    1/2 tsp dried sage (or just use pre made Italian herbs)
    Salt and pepper

    To the blender

    Handful of fresh basil
    2 cups veggie stock

    To complete the soup

    1 tbsp olive oil (for cooking out the paste)
    2 tbsp tomato paste
    1 tbsp unsalted butter

    Cheese toastie

    White sourdough
    Mozzarella
    Cheddar
    Parmesan

    Method

    1. 1

      Preheat your oven to 200°C. On a large baking tray, toss your halved tomatoes, red onion, and chillies with a generous drizzle of olive oil, salt, and pepper.

    2. 2

      Drizzle the sliced head of garlic with a little oil, wrap it tightly in foil, and nestle it onto the tray. Roast for 35–40 minutes until the tomatoes are blistered and the onions are starting to caramelise.

    3. 3

      Once roasted, transfer all the veggies (and those precious juices from the tray) into a high-speed blender. Squeeze the roasted garlic cloves straight out of their skins and into the mix. Add a handful of fresh basil and a splash of the stock, then blitz until completely smooth and vibrant.

    4. 4

      In a pot over medium heat, fry the tomato paste for 1-2 minutes until it darkens slightly - this is key for depth of flavour! Pour in the blended tomato mixture and the remaining stock. Stir in a knob of butter for extra creaminess and let it simmer gently for 10 minutes to let everything marry together.

    5. 5

      While the soup is bubbling, butter the outside of your sourdough slices. On the unbuttered side, pile on your mix of aged cheddar, mozzarella, and parmesan. Don't be shy!

    6. 6

      Heat a pan over medium heat with a little extra butter. Fry the toasties for 3–4 minutes per side, pressing down slightly with your spatula, until the bread is a deep golden brown and the cheese is completely melted and stretchy.

    7. 7

      Ladle the hot soup into big bowls and serve immediately alongside those cheesy toasties.

    Macros

    SOUP ONLY Calories: ~180 | Protein: ~4g | Carbs: ~18g | Fat: ~10g Add a toastie (approximate, varies by cheese quantity and bread size): Calories: ~420 | Protein: ~18g | Carbs: ~32g | Fat: ~24g Full bowl with toastie: ~600 calories | ~22g protein

    *Macros will vary for different brands of ingredients

    Storage

    Soup keeps in the fridge for up to 7 days and freezes beautifully for up to 3 months - this is one of the best soups to batch make and freeze in portions. Thaw overnight and reheat gently on the stove over medium heat, adding a splash of stock or water if it's thickened up. Make the toastie fresh every time, always. A reheated toastie is a crime and you know it.

    Substitutions

    Fresh tomatoes: canned whole tomatoes work in a pinch but roasting fresh is what makes this special, the caramelisation can't be replicated with tinned Veggie stock: chicken stock adds a little more depth and richness if you're not keeping it vegetarian Butter in the soup: a splash of cream works similarly for that silky finish Chilli: leave it out entirely for a completely mild soup, or add more seeds for heat Sourdough: any thick white bread works for the toastie, you just want something sturdy enough to hold the cheese without going soggy

    FAQs

    Can I use a stick blender instead of a high speed blender? Yes - stick blender directly in the pot works fine. Blend thoroughly and pass through a fine sieve afterwards if you want that completely silky, texture-free result. A high speed blender gets you there faster but it's not essential. Why cook out the tomato paste first? Raw tomato paste has a sharp, slightly metallic edge. Cooking it in oil for 1–2 minutes until it darkens caramelises the sugars and removes that rawness, adding a deeper, richer tomato flavour to the finished soup. My soup is too acidic - how do I fix it? A pinch of sugar stirred through balances the acidity immediately. The butter also helps round out sharpness. If you're consistently finding tomato soup too acidic, a small splash of cream stirred through at the end smooths everything out beautifully.
    Print

    Watch the Reel

    Comments

    0 comments

    Leave a Comment

    Loading comments…

    New recipes, straight to you

    Join the list and never miss a recipe drop. No spam, just flavour.