Back to recipes

    Butter Chicken

    BETTER than takeout... This went viral for a reason people! Simple ingredients coupled with a little love and patience and you my friends, have yourself probably one of the better tasting butter chickens you've ever blessed your tastebuds with (humbly said).

    Butter chicken is one of those dishes that people overcomplicate for absolutely no reason. It’s not meant to be stressful. It’s meant to be creamy, comforting, slightly sweet, deeply spiced, and eaten with your hands via flatbread while pretending you’re not going back for seconds. This version starts with a proper yoghurt marinade which does a lot of the heavy lifting here. Let it sit as long as you can be bothered. Overnight is ideal, a few hours is still great, and even 30 minutes will do something. The longer it sits, the more tender and flavour-loaded everything gets, which is exactly what we want. Then we build the sauce properly. Onions, garlic, ginger, spices cooked out until they smell like you know what you’re doing. Tomato base to bring it all together. And the real secret? Cashews blended into the sauce so it turns thick, creamy, and a little bit ridiculous in the best way. It’s rich without being heavy. Spiced without being aggressive. And finished with cream and butter because… obviously. And then there’s the flatbread situation, which is honestly optional but also not really. Soft dough, a little cheese in the middle, pan-fried until golden. It’s giving “why did I just stop ordering takeaway when I can do this.” This is the kind of meal that makes your kitchen smell insane and makes you slightly annoying about it afterwards because you’ll want everyone to try it immediately. Which is fair.
    Prep15
    Cook40
    Serves4-5

    Butter Chicken

    Ingredients

    MetricImperial
    1×
    700g chicken thigh fillets, cubed
    3 tbsp greek yogurt
    2 garlic cloves, minced
    2 tsp ginger, minced
    2 tsp curry powder
    2 tsp garam masala
    1 tsp dried coriander
    1 tsp turmeric
    1 tsp paprika
    1/2 tsp chilli powder
    1/2 tsp cumin
    Salt
    2 tsp ghee for cooking

    Sauce

    2 tsp ghee
    1 brown onion, sliced
    Salt and pepper
    + the exact same seasonings & measurements as above
    2 garlic cloves, minced
    2 tsp ginger, minced
    1.5 tbsp tomato paste
    400ml diced tomatoes, canned
    1/2 cup water
    60g raw natural cashews
    2 tablespoon sugar (optional)
    300ml thickened cream

    Finish with

    2 tbsp unsalted butter

    Flatbreads

    100g self-raising flour
    100g Greek yogurt
    Cheese of choice

    Method

    1. 1

      Combine the chicken in a bowl with greek yogurt and the seasonings listed. Cover and marinade for 1-24 hours. The longer the better.

    2. 2

      Once marinated, in a pan on medium to high heat with ghee, cook off the chicken until its 50% cooked.

    3. 3

      Once the chicken is cooked half way through, remove from the pan into a bowl and set aside.

    4. 4

      In the same pan on medium heat with more ghee, sauté the onions with salt, pepper and the seasonings listed under 'sauce'.

    5. 5

      Once softened, add the garlic and ginger and cook for 30 seconds or until fragrant.

    6. 6

      Add the tomato paste and cook out for an additional minute before adding the tinned tomatoes and water.

    7. 7

      Stir thoroughly to combine ensuring you scrape the bottom of the pan to unstick all of the tasty flavours.

    8. 8

      Add the cashews, lower the heat and allow to simmer for 10-15 minutes or until the cashews have softened.

    9. 9

      Once the cashews are soft, blitz the sauce until smooth and creamy.

    10. 10

      Add the sauce back into the pan followed by the chicken we cooked earlier and all of its juices.

    11. 11

      I'm a basic bitch who likes a sweet butter chicken so I add sugar to taste but this is totally optional!

    12. 12

      Stir in the cream and butter before giving it one final taste to ensure its seasoned to your liking.

    13. 13

      Once you're happy with it, lower the heat to low and let it simmer away while you cook your rice and/or prepare the flatbreads.

    14. 14

      For flatbreads: combine flour and greek yogurt, knead until smooth, cut into four, roll out, add cheese in the middle, fold and seal, roll out again, then cook in a pan with olive oil until golden on both sides.

    15. 15

      Serve the butter chicken finishing with a swirl of cream and some fresh coriander with a side of rice and/or flatbreads and enjoy!

    Macros

    Calories: 580 Protein: 42g Carbs: 18g Fat: 38g Thickened cream and butter are the main calorie drivers - this is a proper indulgent butter chicken and makes no apologies for it. Cashews thicken the sauce and add healthy fat. Add roughly 180 calories per cheesy flatbread.

    *Macros will vary for different brands of ingredients

    Storage

    Keeps in the fridge for up to 5 days and genuinely gets better overnight as the spices deepen into the cream sauce. Reheat gently in a pan over low heat, stirring regularly - cream based sauces can split at high heat so keep it gentle. Freezes well for up to 3 months. Make the flatbreads fresh each time, they take 10 minutes and are never as good reheated.

    Substitutions

    Chicken thighs: breast works but thighs stay juicier through the marinating and cooking process and are the better call here Greek yogurt in the marinade: natural yogurt is a direct swap, same tenderising effect Cashews: blanched almonds blend just as smoothly and do the same job of thickening and enriching the sauce Thickened cream: light cream for fewer calories, coconut cream for a dairy free version with a slightly different but equally delicious flavour profile Ghee: neutral oil works fine, ghee adds a subtle nuttiness that pairs beautifully with the spice blend Sugar: a small amount of honey or maple syrup does the same job of balancing the acidity of the tomatoes if you want a more natural sweetener

    FAQs

    Why only cook the chicken 50% through before removing it? The chicken finishes cooking in the sauce for the final simmer and absorbs all that spiced, creamy flavour as it does. Cooking it all the way through in the pan first and then adding it to the sauce gives you overcooked, dry chicken by the time it's served. Half cooked, finish in the sauce - much juicier result. Why blend the cashews into the sauce? Cashews blended into a curry sauce create an incredibly rich, thick, creamy base without needing as much cream. They add natural fat, body and a subtle nuttiness that is completely undetectable once blended but makes a significant difference to the texture and richness of the final sauce. Let them soften fully in the simmering sauce before blending or you'll get a grainy result. Why add butter at the end? Cold butter stirred through at the very end off the heat emulsifies into the sauce and adds an incredible silkiness and richness - the same technique used in French cooking and in restaurant butter chicken that makes the sauce taste glossy and indulgent rather than just creamy. Don't skip it. How long should I marinate for? Minimum 1 hour, overnight if you can manage it. The yogurt and spices break down the protein in the chicken and season it all the way through - the difference between a 1 hour and a 24 hour marinate is immediately obvious and worth planning ahead for. Can I make the sauce ahead? Yes - the sauce keeps in the fridge for up to 5 days on its own. Make it ahead, reheat gently, add freshly cooked chicken and finish with cream and butter when ready to serve. Great for entertaining because all the effort is done before anyone arrives.
    Print

    Watch the Reel

    Comments

    0 comments

    Leave a Comment

    Loading comments…

    New recipes, straight to you

    Join the list and never miss a recipe drop. No spam, just flavour.