Back to recipes

    Healthy Ice Cream Sandwiches

    A chewy, fudgy, wholefood choc chip ice cream sandwich that tastes completely unreal and is made entirely from real ingredients. 8.8 grams of protein per slice and 7 grams of fibre. A recipe winged in real time and worked out an absolute treat. This is the one.

    The craving hit and it was specific - chewy, fudgy biscuit, creamy chocolate chip ice cream, sandwich situation, but made entirely from wholefoods because I wanted to eat three of them without the aftermath. Challenge accepted and honestly this might be one of the best things I've ever made. I'm not being dramatic. The texture alone is enough to make you question everything you thought you knew about healthy treats. The whole thing is built on a medjool date and peanut butter caramel base that does double duty here - half goes into the biscuit dough and half goes into the ice cream filling. One blend, two components, zero waste and genuinely the smartest thing about this recipe. The caramel is smooth, rich, naturally sweet and has this deep, almost toffee-like flavour that makes both layers taste indulgent in a way that has no business coming from dates and peanut butter. The biscuit dough comes together with rolled oats, raw cacao and lupin flakes mixed through the reserved caramel until it forms this soft, fudgy, deeply chocolatey dough that you will absolutely be eating straight from the bowl before it makes it into the tin. Lupin flakes are a natural protein boost and you can find them on Amazon - but if you don't have them just sub more oats, it works just as beautifully. The dough gets pressed into a lined loaf tin in two layers with the ice cream sandwiched in the middle and the whole thing goes into the freezer to set. The ice cream filling is the other half of that date caramel blended with chickpeas until completely smooth and creamy, loosened with a little of the date soaking water and studded with chopped dark chocolate. I know chickpeas in ice cream sounds unhinged but they blend completely smooth and add this incredible creamy body along with a solid protein hit that makes the whole thing genuinely satisfying rather than just sweet. You cannot taste them. I promise. Three hours in the freezer and then slice into twelve pieces - and honestly have one immediately while you're at it because the texture at that point is absolutely insane. Chewy, fudgy biscuit, creamy chocolate ice cream, the whole experience. And here's the thing - you must let it thaw for at least 10 minutes before eating. Straight from frozen does it a complete disservice. That slightly softened, fudgy biscuit with the creamy centre is the whole point and those 10 minutes are completely worth the wait. 251 calories, 8.8 grams of protein, 7 grams of fibre per slice. Wholefood ice cream sandwiches that taste like a treat and actually keep you full. This is the one.
    Prep25
    Cook0
    Serves12

    Healthy Ice Cream Sandwiches

    Ingredients

    MetricImperial
    1×

    Date Caramel Base

    250g medjool dates, pitted and soaked in boiled water for 10 minutes
    ½ cup smooth peanut butter
    2 tbsp full fat milk (sub coconut cream for dairy free, full fat helps with freezing)
    1 tsp vanilla bean paste
    Pinch of salt
    3 tbsp maple syrup

    Ice Cream Filling

    Half the date caramel base
    400g chickpeas, drained
    110g dark chocolate 70% or above, roughly chopped
    Date soaking water to loosen as needed

    Biscuit Dough

    Half the date caramel base
    ½ cup rolled oats
    30g raw cacao powder
    ½ cup lupin flakes (sub more oats if you don't have them)
    Date soaking water to help combine if needed

    Method

    1. 1

      Soak the pitted dates in boiled water for 10 minutes until completely soft. Drain and reserve the soaking water.

    2. 2

      Add the dates, peanut butter, milk, vanilla, salt and maple syrup to a blender and blitz until completely smooth and caramel-like. Scoop half into a separate bowl and set aside for the biscuit dough.

    3. 3

      To the remaining half in the blender add the drained chickpeas and blend until completely smooth, loosening with the reserved date water as needed until you reach a creamy, scoopable consistency. Stir through the chopped dark chocolate. Ice cream done.

    4. 4

      For the biscuit dough, blend the oats, cacao powder and lupin flakes together until fine. Add to the reserved caramel and mix with your hands until a soft, fudgy dough forms. Add a splash of date water if it needs help coming together.

    5. 5

      Line a loaf tin with cling wrap. Split the dough in two equal portions. Press one half into the base of the lined tin. Pour the ice cream filling over the top and spread evenly. Press the second half of the dough flat between two pieces of cling wrap to match the size of the tin then lay it on top as the lid, pressing down gently.

    6. 6

      Freeze for a minimum of 3 hours. Once set, lift out of the tin and slice into 12 pieces. Have one immediately because the texture at this point is absolutely insane. Transfer the rest to airtight containers and return to the freezer.

    7. 7

      Remove from the freezer and allow to thaw for at least 10 minutes before eating — this is non-negotiable for the best possible texture. That slightly softened, chewy, fudgy biscuit with the creamy ice cream centre is the whole experience and eating it straight from frozen does it a disservice. The wait is genuinely worth it.

    Macros

    Per slice (12 slices): Calories: 251 kcal Protein: 8.8g protein Fat: 10g fat Carbs: 34g Fibre: 7g

    *Macros will vary for different brands of ingredients

    Storage

    Keeps in the freezer in an airtight container for up to 6 weeks. Slice before freezing so you can grab individual pieces without having to thaw and recut the whole thing. Always allow 10 minutes thaw time before eating - straight from frozen does the texture a complete disservice and those 10 minutes make all the difference between good and genuinely unreal.

    Substitutions

    Medjool dates: regular dried dates soaked for longer work but medjool are softer, more caramel-like and give a noticeably better result in both layers Peanut butter: almond butter or cashew butter are direct swaps, sunflower seed butter for nut free Lupin flakes: more rolled oats as noted. Lupin flakes are worth tracking down on Amazon for the protein boost Dark chocolate: anything 65% and above but any chocolate you like will work, just won't make it refined sugar free Full fat milk: coconut cream for dairy free as noted, any plant milk works in a pinch but the higher the fat content the better to help with the texture when it freezes

    FAQs

    Can I actually not taste the chickpeas? They add a slight element of 'savouriness' but once blended completely smooth with the date caramel they disappear entirely. What you taste is chocolate, caramel and creaminess. The chickpeas are just adding body, protein and fibre without contributing any flavour of their own. Why soak the dates in boiled water? Softens them completely so they blend into a smooth, lump-free caramel rather than leaving fibrous bits throughout. The soaking water is also used throughout the recipe to loosen both the ice cream and the dough so don't throw it away - it's flavoured with natural date sweetness and does real work. Why does it need to thaw for 10 minutes? Straight from frozen the biscuit layers are rock hard and the ice cream filling is icy rather than creamy. Ten minutes at room temperature brings the biscuit back to that chewy, fudgy texture and the filling to a soft, scoopable consistency. That combination is the whole point of this recipe and it cannot be rushed. Why press the top layer between cling wrap before adding it? The dough is soft and sticky and trying to press it directly onto the ice cream filling will mix the layers together. Pressing it flat to the right size between cling wrap first means you can lay it on top cleanly and evenly without disturbing the filling underneath.
    Print

    Watch the Reel

    Comments

    0 comments

    Leave a Comment

    Loading comments…

    New recipes, straight to you

    Join the list and never miss a recipe drop. No spam, just flavour.